$1.29

$1.29

$1.29

$1.29

$1.69

$1.29

Blackberry

$1.29

$1.29

$1.29

$1.29

$1.29

$2.50

18.5 oz.

$2.50

18.5 oz UNSWEETENED

$9.19

Two slices of French toast filled with cream cheese batter and your choice of blueberry or raspberry filling topped with powdered sugar.

$12.64

Crab Cake with ham, poached eggs and Holland side sauce on top.

$5.16

$5.16

$6.43

Sweet Cream or Birkett Mills Buckwheat available

$7.69

$8.96

Sweet Cream or Birkett Mills Buckwheat available.

$10.34

$8.96

Three slices made with texas toast served with confectionery sugar (Substitution of breads offered)

$13.67

Two pancakes or french toast, 2 eggs, toast, and homefries with your choice of bacon, ham or sausage

$12.98

House Favorite! An oval flatbread with a skim coat of garlic butter, swiss cheese, tomato, ham, and scrambled eggs.

$12.98

A layer of tots with diced ham and bacon, 2 eggs any style, hollandaise sauce and cheddar cheese

$12.18

Half order of gravy with two eggs over top and half order of homefries

$8.27

Half order of homefries topped with sausage gravy and toast

Add Brown Sugar, Raisins, or Honey for a small upcharge

$1.94

$2.06

White, Italian, Wheat, Multigrain, Soft Rye, Texas, Cinnamon Raisin, Our Own Roll

$2.75

$2.75

Plain, Onion, or Everything

$4.59

$4.59

$4.59

Patties or Links

Full or Half Order

$2.75

2 oz.

$5.51

Two eggs with toast

$8.61

Two eggs with toast, and your choice of bacon, ham or sausage

$11.26

Two eggs with toast and your choice of canned or dinermade corned beef hash

$6.54

One egg on a dinermade roll, toast, bagel, or english muffin, your choice of meat and cheese

$8.61

Two eggs, choice of meat and cheese, wrapped in a flour tortilla

$12.64

Two poached eggs served on an english muffin with a 4oz slice of tavern ham, topped with Hollandaise sauce.

$10.11

No Meat! Two egg omelet with raw veggies, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, salsa, and cheddar

$12.06

With choice of bacon, ham or sausage, cheese and raw veggies: Mushrooms, green peppers or onion

$8.05

This original thick & flavorful hot sauce recipe was created in 1998 by Dan "Sudsy" Mitchell for friends & family. It continues to gain a following among those who don't want to sacrifice flavor for heat. Allergens: fish, soy

$28.75

This handcrafted pottery mug features the Penn Yan Diner logo and is sure to make a simply retrolicious addition to your table.

$6.77

$6.77

$6.77