Sort:
$$$
315-531-4700
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_11_i392.png
131 Main StreetPenn YanNY14527

Bubble Tea

Emporium Beverage Bar
$$$
315-531-4700
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_7_i222.png
131 Main StreetPenn YanNY14527

Candy

Keuka Candy
Emporium
$$$
315-536-5454
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_13_i352.png
823 E Lake RdPenn YanNY14527

Sandwiches & Deli

The Olney Place
$$$
607-292-6927
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_7_i372.png
14109 Keuka Village RdHammondsportNY14840

American

The Switz
$$$
315-536-4026
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_38_i61.png
5 Main StreetPenn YanNY14527

American

Angel's Family
Restaurant
$$$
315-531-8700
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_19_i202.png
2447 State Route 54APenn YanNY14527

Barbeque

The BBQ Shack
Donuts Done Right
$$$
315-531-9282
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_19_i152.png
108 Main StreetPenn YanNY14527

Chinese

Chen's Garden
$$$
315-536-5852
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_39_i31.png
10 Main StreetPenn YanNY14527

American

Keuka Restaurant
$$$
315-536-6004
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_8_i212.png
131 East Elm StreetPenn YanNY14527

Diner

Penn Yan Diner
$$$
315-536-4640
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_37_i81.png
3103 Skyline DrivePenn YanNY14527

American

Skyline Trading Post
$$$
315-536-8062
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_29_i131.png
124 E. Elm StreetPenn YanNY14527

American

Wagner Restaurant
$$$
315-536-1292
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_5_i242.png
230A Lake Street PlazaPenn YanNY14527
Lake Street
Plaza Theatre
$$$
607-569-2001
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_6_i342.png
46 Main StHammondsportNY14840

Convenience Store

Quikshoppe
$$$
607-224-0006
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_9_i282.png
70 Shethar StHammondsportNY14840

Bar & Grill

Timber Stone Grill
$$$
607-246-4065
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_9_i402.png
31 Shethar StreetHammondsportNY14840

Italian

Union Block
Hammondsport
$$$
315-536-8062
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_11_i332.png
124 E Elm StPenn YanNY14527

American

Wagner DINNER MENU
$$$
315-536-6576
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_45_i101.png
2940 NY54APenn YanNY14527

American

Antique Inn
Restaurant
$$$
315-521-1422
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_12_i172.png
3700 Route 14APenn YanNY14527

Pretzels

Auntie Anne's
$$$
315-536-9036
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_28_i91.png
221 E Elm StreetPenn YanNY14527

Bar & Grill

Liberty Restaurant
$$$
315-719-3683
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_41_i111.png
146 Main StPenn YanNY14527

Cakes & Bakery

Sabrina's
Bake Shoppe
$$$
315-531-8500
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_40_i41.png
301 Lake StreetPenn YanNY14527

American

Top of the Lake
$$$
607-246-4065
https://www.keukatogo.com/v_44_i71.png
Water StreetPenn YanNY14527

Italian

Union Block
Penn Yan

To order, click items on the menu!

Penn Yan Diner

The Penn Yan Diner is Retrolicious serving Dinermade Yummy for your Tummy food. The current Mom and Pop couple, Sean and Carrie Ahearn, strive to provide a cheerful and friendly dining experience. Our goal is to satisfy your hunger with flavorful food, ultimately filling your stomach with contentment.

Cuisine Type

Diner

$$

Address

131 East Elm Street
Penn YanNY14527

Phone Number

(315) 536 -6004

Delivery Hours

Monday
9:45AM - 1:55PM
Tuesday
9:45AM - 1:55PM
Wednesday
9:45AM - 1:55PM
Thursday
9:45AM - 1:55PM
Friday
9:45AM - 1:55PM
9:45AM - 6:45PM
Saturday
9:45AM - 1:55PM
Sunday
10:00AM - 1:45PM
Download as PDF

Legend

  • New Item Icon New

FEATURED SPECIALS

Today's specials

Special of the week

Breakfast feature

Back by popular demand!

DINERMADE PIE

It's back! Selections vary each week.

FROM THE FLAT TOP

Sweet Cream Pancakes or Birkett Mills Buckwheat Available

SAUSAGE GRAVY & BISCUITS

Jimmy Dean Original Sausage used in Carries Rue-Based recipe. Served over Shawn's scratch made baking powder biscuits.

BREAKFAST SIDES

Food Safety Warning

CONSUMING RAW OR UNDERCOOKED MEATS, POULTRY, SEAFOOD, SHELLFISH, OR EGGS MAY INCREASE YOUR RISK OF FOODBORNE ILLNESS

EGGS

OMELETS

COOL DINER STUFF

MILKSHAKES

COFFEE

Locally roasted by Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters

Pricing

Prices for Penn Yan Diner on Keuka To Go are slightly higher than dine in. This allows us to bring you the convenience of ordering online and having food from Upstate New York's best diner delivered hot and fresh to your door.

MAKE IT A PLATTER

Platters come with a cup of soup or side salad, plus one side: applesauce, cole slaw, cottage cheese, or french fries. Just add this item to make your lunch entree a platter.

BURGERS

Burgers are 1/3 Lb. hand pressed and seasoned with onion soup, worcestershire and spices. Served on Sean's famous dinermade rolls.

HOT SANDWICHES

Sandwiches include chips and a pickle

CHICKEN

COLD SANDWICHES

All sandwiches come dressed with lettuce and tomato.

SALADS

Dressings include 1,000 Island, Bleu Cheese, Caesar, French, Honey Mustard, Italian, or Ranch

LUNCH SIDES

Carnitas

Fish fry - available fridays

Previous

item thumbnail
Beer Batter Fish Sandwich

$11.49

Served on one of our dinermade rolls with lettuce, tomato, and a side of tartar sauce.

item thumbnail
Hot Pastrami with Cheese

$12.41

Pastrami on rye with Swiss Cheese and a side of spicy brown mustard. Served with chips and a pickle.

item thumbnail
Cajun Fish Sandwich

$10.11

Swai Fish coated with Cajun seasoning served on a Dinermade roll on top of coleslaw

Rhubarb Pie Slice

$4.93

item thumbnail
Kentucky Hot Brown

$12.41

Grilled turkey, bacon, tomato, and cheddar served over two potato pancakes.

item thumbnail
Pork Schnitzel Sandwich

$10.11

Boneless pork coated with seasoned breadcrumbs and grilled on the flat top. Served on a Dinermade roll.

item thumbnail
Fried Bologna Sandwich

$11.83

Fried bologna, onions, and swiss cheese on Texas toast.

item thumbnail
Mushroom Swiss Burger

$8.96

1/3 Lb Hand Pressed patty seasoned with worcestershire and onion soup mix, topped with sauteed mushrooms and swiss and served on a dinermade roll.

item thumbnail
Monte Cristo

$11.83

Turkey and Ham served sandwich style on French Toast with honey mustard and swiss cheese.

Key Lime Pie Slice

$4.93

item thumbnail
Ice Cream Sundae Waffle

$9.50

Sweet Cream or Birkett Mills buckwheat waffle with either chocolate or vanilla ice cream and strawberries with whipped cream

item thumbnail
French Onion Grilled Cheese

$7.19

Grilled onions, swiss, and provolone, melted between two slices of toasty bread. Served with au jus.

item thumbnail
Loaded Chicken Tots

$12.64

A helping of tater tots topped with bacon, chicken tenders, cheddar cheese, and your choice of ranch or BBQ sauce.

item thumbnail
Breakfast Quesadilla

$8.04

Choice of meat and cheese pressed on the flattop in a flour tortilla.

Red Raspberry Pie Slice

$4.93

item thumbnail
Turkey Club Flatbread

$12.52

Turkey, pesto, bacon, mozzarella, and tomato on a garlic grilled flatbread.

item thumbnail
Spicy Ham Grilled Cheese

$10.34

Capicola ham and Swiss cheese grilled together on ciabatta. Served with chips and a pickle.

item thumbnail
Chocolate Cream Pie Slice

$4.93

Power Up Sandwich

$6.31

Ham, egg over medium, pepper jack cheese, tomato and spinach on multigrain toast

item thumbnail
Cuban Sandwich

$12.41

Carnitas Pork and ham, swiss cheese, and a pickle served on a grilled long roll (image shows focaccia bread, currently serving on a long roll)

item thumbnail
Philly Cheesesteak Omelette

$12.64

Our 2 egg omelette with thin sliced sirloin shredded and seasoned on the grill with provolone and sauteed onions and peppers

item thumbnail
Carnitas Quesadilla

$12.63

Carnitas Pork with your choice of cheese, sauteed onions and peppers, salsa and sour cream.

  • New Item Icon New