12oz. Mountain Dew
12oz. Diet Pepsi
12oz. Sierra Mist
Bubly Sparkling Water
12oz. Root Beer
Bar & Grill
Cakes & Bakery
Sandwiches & Deli
Bar & Grill
The Penn Yan Diner is Retrolicious serving Dinermade Yummy for your Tummy food. The current Mom and Pop couple, Sean and Carrie Ahearn, strive to provide a cheerful and friendly dining experience. Our goal is to satisfy your hunger with flavorful food, ultimately filling your stomach with contentment.
(315) 536 -6004
Provided by Keuka To Go
Back by popular demand!
It's back! Selections vary each week.
Sweet Cream Pancakes or Birkett Mills Buckwheat Available
Sweet Cream or Birkett Mills Buckwheat available
Sweet Cream or Birkett Mills Buckwheat available.
Three slices made with texas toast served with confectionery sugar (Substitution of breads offered)
Two pancakes or french toast, 2 eggs, toast, and homefries with your choice of bacon, ham or sausage
House Favorite! An oval flatbread with a skim coat of garlic butter, swiss cheese, tomato, ham, and scrambled eggs.
A layer of tots with diced ham and bacon, 2 eggs any style, hollandaise sauce and cheddar cheese
Jimmy Dean Original Sausage used in Carries Rue-Based recipe. Served over Shawn's scratch made baking powder biscuits.
Add Brown Sugar, Raisins, or Honey for a small upcharge
Grapes, blueberries, and watermelon
White, Italian, Wheat, Multigrain, Soft Rye, Texas, Cinnamon Raisin, Our Own Roll
Plain, Onion, or Everything
Patties or Links
Canned or Dinermade
Full or Half Order
CONSUMING RAW OR UNDERCOOKED MEATS, POULTRY, SEAFOOD, SHELLFISH, OR EGGS MAY INCREASE YOUR RISK OF FOODBORNE ILLNESS
Two eggs with toast
Two eggs with toast, and your choice of bacon, ham or sausage
6oz. sirloin cooked to your liking with 2 eggs and your choice of toast.
Two eggs with toast and your choice of canned or dinermade corned beef hash
One egg on a dinermade roll, toast, bagel, or english muffin, your choice of meat and cheese
Two eggs, choice of meat and cheese, wrapped in a flour tortilla
Two poached eggs served on an english muffin with a 4oz slice of tavern ham, topped with Hollandaise sauce.
This original thick & flavorful hot sauce recipe was created in 1998 by Dan "Sudsy" Mitchell for friends & family. It continues to gain a following among those who don't want to sacrifice flavor for heat. Allergens: fish, soy
This handcrafted pottery mug features the Penn Yan Diner logo and is sure to make a simply retrolicious addition to your table.
Locally roasted by Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters
Prices for Penn Yan Diner on Keuka To Go are slightly higher than dine in. This allows us to bring you the convenience of ordering online and having food from Upstate New York's best diner delivered hot and fresh to your door.
Platters come with a cup of soup or side salad, plus one side: applesauce, cole slaw, cottage cheese, or french fries. Just add this item to make your lunch entree a platter.
Burgers are 1/3 Lb. hand pressed and seasoned with onion soup, worcestershire and spices. Served on Sean's famous dinermade rolls.
Sandwiches include chips and a pickle
Dinermade corned beef, saurkraut, 1,000 island dressing with swiss on grilled seedless rye
Deli turkey, dinermade cole slaw, 1,000 island dressing, with swiss on grilled seedless rye
Red Osier Roast Beef on choice of bread, smothered in beef gravy. Try it on the Grilled Dinermade Bun!
Grilled Deli sliced Turkey on choice of bread, smothered in turkey gravy.
Grilled on the flat top. Your choice of cheese and bread. Add ham or bacon for an extra treat!
All sandwiches come dressed with lettuce and tomato.
Your choice of deli meat, tuna, egg, or chicken salad, with lettuce, tomato, bacon, and mayo on toasted bread
Deli sliced ham, turkey, or roast beef on your choice of bread, with lettuce, tomato and mayo
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on toasted bread
Choice of chicken, tuna or egg salad on your choice of bread
Cup or Bowl
Dressings include 1,000 Island, Bleu Cheese, Caesar, French, Honey Mustard, Italian, or Ranch